*School Library Journal
(*starred
review): "Deem's carefully
researched photo-essay examines the newest
information on these remarkable finds and pieces it with other known facts
to present as clear a picture of [Iron Age] people as possible under the circumstances.
Some are obviously sacrificial victims; others may be guilty of some crime or act
punishable by death. The bodies themselves, in various stages of preservation and decay,
whisper down the ages in half-heard, almost indecipherable voices, hinting at religious
beliefs and justice codes unknown to us. A chapter on the bogs themselves gives readers a clear understanding of this unusual preservation
process, and the whole is lavished with
crisp full-color photos (and sepia-toned historical ones). Obviously the
high 'ick' factor here will attract cursory attention, but [this book] should motivate some intense and extremely interesting research."
*Booklist (*starred
review): "Deem begins with the discovery of a man buried in
a peat bog near Grauballe, Denmark; originally thought to be an accident victim of the
last century, he turned out to be a sacrifice victim from 2,000 years ago. Deem goes on,
in an exceptionally well-organized and riveting text,
to
describe other early peoples of Europe and how they were preserved in bogs. He also clearly explains the make-up of the bogs and
their preservation qualities. Most striking here,
however, are the color and black-and-white photographs that appear on every page.
There
are excellent photos of artifacts and scientific procedure, but it is the pictures of the mummies themselves that mesmerize.
Startling in their clarity, it is impossible not to look at these pictures and wonder
about the people shown in them."
Children's Literature:
"If the cover doesn't grab kids then the pictures on the inside will. This
fascinating book tells about the various bodies
that have been recovered from the bogs of Northern Europe. The book explains the
differences between fen peat and bog peat and the reasons why the latter can preserve
human remains. What scientists have learned from these preserved bodies makes for
interesting reading. For example, they can tell
what the last meal was, whether the person died of natural causes or was a sacrificial
victim, and with the use of computers, the faces and bodies of these bog mummies have been
reconstructed. It is eerie, especially the
pictures, but it also tells much about life in the past.
As scientific skills increase, we may learn even more. Pair this with related books about
other mummies such as Tanaka's The Buried City of Pompeii and Discovering the
Iceman; Reinhard's Discovering the Inca Ice Maiden; Getz's Frozen Girl
and Bunting's I am the Mummy Heb-Nefert. There is a bibliography and index."
The Horn Book:
"A fascinating, if gruesome, look at the
history and science of preserved human remains uncovered
in peat bogs in Ireland, England, the Netherlands, Denmark, and Germany. Discoveries of
bog mummies, skeletons, and body fragments are described, as are the scientific methods of
investigating them, One chapter also details other items found in the bogs (jewelry, a
wagon, a cauldron), while another describes the ecology of the bogs.... The text is
both engaging and accessible, and the
starkly dramatic photographs
are given dignity by the spacious and understated page
design."
Parents' ChoiceŽ:
"For
budding archaeologists, or any child interested in exploring scientific
mysteries, James Deem's straightforward text and superior choice of
photographs (many of them taken at the sites where naturally mummified bog
bodies have been found) unfold a compelling story of Iron Age Man. The few
hundred bodies discovered since the 1600s are, for the most part, remarkably
well-preserved. The damp, cool soil of ancient peat bogs kept the bodies
intact for 2500-3000 years, so much so that scientists have been able to
discover what these ancestors ate and, in many cases, how they died. Because
many bog bodies appear to have died by violence, scientists suspect they were
victims of human sacrifice. One close-up, of a body named "the Tollund
man" (after the bog where it was found), reveals a peaceful face that
looks to be serenely sleeping. This, and other photographs will not soon be
forgotten. Not for everyone, this is a memorable and worthwhile
effort."
KLIATT:
"Those fascinated by
mummies will be taken with Bodies from the Bog. Enriched with color
photographs of gruesome human remains from bogs in Ireland, England, Germany,
Denmark, and Holland, Deem's text includes both the history of these human
remains and relics as well as a scientific explanation of why after thousands of
years the bodies are still in such remarkable shape. For example, bodies lost in
fens deteriorate, but peat bogs full of sphagnan, a substance in sphagnum moss,
prevent the growth of microbes. Mysteries still surround these ancient remains.
Who were they? Why were many of them put into the bogs in the first place, some
with their throats slit and others with ropes around their necks? Were they
criminals, or deformed children, or witches, or human sacrifices? This
brief but tantalizing book with its bibliography and index will prove
irresistible to young readers who will find the science accessible and clearly
explained."